I recently read somewhere, most excellent and genteel reader, about a contest in England to choose the worst lyrics to a song ever.
I don’t really know about this sort of thing. It is a fairly obvious effort to cash in on a less appealing aspect of human nature, the propensity to sneer.
Having said that, the winner did seem worthy, being from a song called “Life” by Des’ree.
For those who did not hear, the offending lines were:
“I don’t want to see a ghost,
It’s the sight that I fear most
I’d rather have a piece of toast
Watch the evening news.”
Now I don’t want to sound negative, but really could anyone come up with the above then put down his or her pen and think “that’s a good day’s work”? Surely not.
I understand that it has become something of a joke and generally gets mentioned in “Worst Lyrics Ever” discussions, so I suppose that is some sort of comfort for the writer.
Another one that I have trouble with is John Schumann’s song “I Was Only 19”.
Most Australians are familiar with this very popular song and it would take a stronger man than me to listen to it without being moved by the plight of the Vietnam veterans to whom it is a tribute.
Of course, that doesn’t mean that the song itself shouldn’t be held up to artistic scrutiny.
I ask you to scrute the following lines:
“Frankie kicked a mine the day that mankind kicked the moon,
God help me. He was going home in June.”
Presumably Schumann is suggesting that it was a bitter irony that Frankie should have been seriously injured, probably killed – it is not made clear, at a time that his departure was imminent.
Unfortunately that doesn’t quite work.
Man landed on the moon on 16 July 1969. I can still remember getting the day off school. Mum bought me a chocolate doughnut for lunch.
That being the case, Frankie had almost a whole year to wait before he was going home. The tour of Vietnam was one year. In other works, Frankie had practically all of his tour to wait before he got home.
That is not really what troubles me. What troubles me is that Schumann has used artistic licence to strain history and good taste in order to rhyme “moon” with “June”. Again, one cannot imagine a feeling of achievement flooding through him after that effort.
That pitiful rhyme has long been the most tedious cliché in verse. In this case “soon” would surely have been a far preferable rhyme.
Finally, I draw your attention to the perennially problematic “Macarthur Park”. There is practically no line in the song that could not be held up to ridicule by anyone who wished so to do. I don’t really need to do that here.
I was listening to it recently during a quieter moment. I blush slightly to confess that it was not the deliciously cracked Richard Harris version, but the slightly spicier one by Donna Summer. When pain and anguish rack the brow, I find that electric drums do a lot to ease the pain.
Anyway, the song had just started and I knew that the pinging of the electric drums would be with me soon. I was half dreaming but for some reason the following lines from the first verse penetrated my consciousness:
“..Between the parted pages and were pressed
In love’s hot fevered iron
Like a striped pair of pants”
I won’t dwell on what this means, I don’t have the slightest idea. I don’t understand how being between the parted pages would work, I have no experience of being pressed by love’s iron and although I can accept that such an appliance might be hot, I don’t see how it can have a fever.
What really struck me, though, is that I thought Donna was singing “..a stripy pair of pants”. That would have been ludicrous enough, but it turns out that the word is “striped”. To make the song scan you have to give it 2 syllables by giving full value to the “e”. Stripe-ed.
What bunkum. Surely when the lyrics don’t make any sense at all, you should at least be able to pronounce them naturally?
There is not really any point in suggesting an alternative. The song is too well established and is already surrounded in sufficient controversy. All I ask is that in future a little more care is taken. A little more care and a lot less chemical stimulation.